Sewage Treatment Plants (STPs) play a crucial role in modern urban infrastructure, helping cities manage wastewater, protect natural water bodies, and support water recycling initiatives. Across India and globally, regulatory authorities evaluate STP performance using several discharge parameters—among which Biological Oxygen Demand (BOD) is one of the most widely monitored indicators.
However, a growing concern among environmental engineers, municipal bodies, and industrial water users is this: many STPs successfully meet prescribed BOD discharge limits but still fail to qualify treated water for reuse applications. This paradox raises serious questions about treatment adequacy, regulatory frameworks, and long-term water sustainability.
This article explores why meeting BOD norms alone is insufficient, the hidden contaminants that affect reuse quality, and what treatment upgrades are required to make wastewater truly reusable.
Understanding the Role of BOD in Sewage Treatment
Biological Oxygen Demand measures the amount of dissolved oxygen required by microorganisms to biologically decompose organic matter present in wastewater. In simpler terms, it reflects the organic pollution load of sewage.
High BOD indicates high biodegradable organic content, which—if discharged untreated—can deplete oxygen in rivers, lakes, and streams, harming aquatic ecosystems.
Regulatory agencies therefore prescribe BOD discharge limits (for example, 10–30 mg/L depending on reuse/discharge category) to ensure treated effluent does not cause environmental oxygen depletion.
When an STP achieves these limits, it signifies:
- Effective biological treatment
- Proper aeration performance
- Adequate microbial degradation of organic waste
But here lies the limitation: BOD measures only biodegradable organic matter—not the full spectrum of contaminants present in wastewater.
Why Meeting BOD Limits Alone Is Not Enough
Water reuse—whether for irrigation, industrial processes, landscaping, flushing, or potable reuse—demands far higher water quality than basic discharge compliance.
An STP may produce effluent with low BOD yet still contain:
- Dissolved salts
- Nutrients
- Pathogens
- Heavy metals
- Synthetic chemicals
- Microplastics
- Non-biodegradable organics
These contaminants do not significantly influence BOD readings but can make treated water unsafe or unsuitable for reuse.
Therefore, BOD compliance ≠ Reuse compliance.
Key Reasons STPs Fail Reuse Standards Despite Meeting BOD Norms
1. Residual Nutrients: Nitrogen and Phosphorus
Conventional biological treatment systems are designed primarily to remove organic matter—not nutrients.
As a result, treated effluent often retains:
- Ammonia
- Nitrates
- Nitrites
- Phosphates
Impact on Reuse:
Agricultural Irrigation
- Excess nitrogen disrupts soil nutrient balance
- Over-fertilization damages crops
- Groundwater nitrate contamination risk
Surface Irrigation & Landscaping
- Nutrient overload causes algal blooms
- Leads to eutrophication in water bodies
Industrial Reuse
- Nutrients contribute to biofouling in cooling towers and pipelines
Without nutrient removal processes like biological nutrient removal (BNR) or chemical precipitation, reuse compliance remains unattainable.
2. Dissolved Salts and Total Dissolved Solids (TDS)
BOD testing does not measure dissolved inorganic content. Yet municipal sewage often carries high salt loads from:
- Domestic detergents
- Industrial discharge
- Water softeners
- Urban runoff
Reuse Risks:
Agriculture
- Soil salinity increases
- Reduces crop yield
- Affects seed germination
Industrial Cooling
- Causes scaling on heat exchangers
- Reduces thermal efficiency
Boiler Feed Applications
- High TDS leads to corrosion and deposition
To control salts, advanced processes like Reverse Osmosis (RO) or Electrodialysis are required—far beyond standard secondary treatment.
3. Pathogens and Microbial Contamination
BOD analysis does not account for disease-causing microorganisms.
Even when organic matter is removed, treated water may still contain:
- E. coli
- Fecal coliform
- Salmonella
- Viruses
- Protozoa (Giardia, Cryptosporidium)
Public Health Implications:
Irrigation of Edible Crops
- Direct contamination risk
Urban Landscaping & Parks
- Human exposure through aerosols
Toilet Flushing & Building Reuse
- Indoor pathogen spread
Construction & Dust Suppression
- Airborne microbial transmission
Effective reuse demands disinfection through:
- UV treatment
- Chlorination
- Ozonation
- Advanced oxidation
Without robust pathogen control, reuse approvals are denied regardless of BOD levels.
4. Presence of Heavy Metals
Municipal sewage often receives industrial wastewater—legally or illegally discharged—introducing metals such as:
- Lead
- Chromium
- Cadmium
- Mercury
- Nickel
These contaminants:
- Do not significantly affect BOD
- Persist after biological treatment
- Accumulate in soil and crops
Reuse Consequences:
- Food chain contamination
- Toxicity to plants
- Groundwater pollution
- Industrial product contamination
Removal requires chemical precipitation, ion exchange, or membrane filtration.
5. Synthetic and Emerging Chemical Pollutants
Modern wastewater contains thousands of synthetic compounds, including:
- Pharmaceuticals
- Hormones
- Personal care products
- Detergents
- PFAS (“forever chemicals”)
- Pesticides
- Microplastics
These are largely non-biodegradable and therefore invisible to BOD testing.
Reuse Risks:
- Endocrine disruption in humans and wildlife
- Toxic accumulation in agriculture
- Industrial process contamination
- Potable reuse safety concerns
Advanced Oxidation Processes (AOPs), activated carbon, and nanofiltration are needed to remove these pollutants.
6. Incomplete Tertiary Treatment
Many STPs stop treatment at the secondary (biological) stage because discharge norms may already be met.
However, reuse requires tertiary and advanced treatment, such as:
- Pressure sand filtration
- Activated carbon filtration
- Ultrafiltration (UF)
- Reverse Osmosis (RO)
- Ozonation
- UV disinfection
Without these polishing steps, treated water may still contain:
- Suspended solids
- Turbidity
- Color
- Odor
- Trace contaminants
Thus, plants meeting BOD limits but lacking tertiary systems fail reuse audits.
7. Turbidity and Total Suspended Solids (TSS)
Even if biodegradable organics are removed, fine suspended particles can remain.
High turbidity affects reuse by:
- Shielding pathogens from disinfection
- Clogging irrigation systems
- Fouling industrial membranes
- Reducing aesthetic acceptability
Filtration and coagulation-flocculation processes are essential to address this gap.
8. Operational and Maintenance Challenges
Treatment performance is not determined by design alone. Operational inefficiencies often cause reuse failures.
Common issues include:
- Poor aeration control
- Sludge bulking
- Inadequate return activated sludge (RAS) rates
- Equipment downtime
- Hydraulic overloading
- Bypass discharge
Even when BOD readings remain compliant, these inefficiencies degrade overall effluent quality.
The Regulatory Shift: From Discharge to Reuse
Water-stressed regions—including many parts of India—are transitioning from “treat and discharge” to “treat and reuse.”
Reuse standards are significantly stricter and multi-dimensional.
Typical parameters monitored include:
- BOD
- COD (Chemical Oxygen Demand)
- TSS
- TDS
- Nutrients (N & P)
- Fecal coliform
- Residual chlorine
- Heavy metals
- Oil & grease
- Turbidity
An STP optimized only for BOD removal cannot meet this expanded compliance framework.
Technologies Required to Achieve Reuse Compliance
To bridge the gap between discharge and reuse, STPs must integrate advanced treatment systems.
1. Membrane Filtration
- Ultrafiltration removes fine solids and pathogens
- Reverse Osmosis removes dissolved salts and metals
2. Advanced Oxidation Processes
- Ozone
- Hydrogen peroxide
- UV-AOP combinations
These destroy refractory organics and pharmaceuticals.
3. Activated Carbon Filtration
- Adsorbs odor, color, and chemical contaminants
4. Nutrient Removal Systems
- Anoxic-aerobic processes
- Chemical dosing (alum, ferric)
5. High-Efficiency Disinfection
- UV sterilization
- Chlorine dioxide
- Ozonation
Importance of Multi-Parameter Monitoring
Continuous monitoring is essential to ensure reuse readiness.
Key performance indicators include:
| Parameter | Importance in Reuse |
|---|---|
| COD | Measures total oxidizable pollutants |
| TSS | Indicates filtration efficiency |
| TDS | Determines suitability for industrial/agri use |
| Pathogens | Public health safety |
| Nutrients | Soil & ecological impact |
| Heavy Metals | Toxicity risk |
Real-time sensors and SCADA systems are increasingly used for compliance tracking.
Sludge Management: An Overlooked Factor
Poor sludge handling can indirectly affect treated water quality.
Challenges include:
- Sludge carryover
- Inadequate dewatering
- Odor generation
- Pathogen regrowth
Proper sludge digestion, drying, and disposal ensure stable plant performance and reuse safety.
Energy, Cost, and Infrastructure Constraints
Many municipalities hesitate to upgrade STPs due to:
- High capital investment
- Energy consumption of RO systems
- Skilled manpower needs
- Membrane replacement costs
However, the long-term economics favor reuse:
- Reduced freshwater extraction
- Lower industrial water procurement cost
- Sustainable urban water cycles
Case for Decentralized and Modular Reuse Systems
Modern infrastructure planning promotes:
- Decentralized STPs
- Modular tertiary units
- On-site reuse plants
Benefits include:
- Lower conveyance losses
- Faster reuse deployment
- Scalable capacity expansion
Environmental and Economic Benefits of Achieving Reuse Standards
When STPs go beyond BOD compliance, cities unlock major advantages:
Water Security
Reduces dependence on groundwater and freshwater reservoirs.
Industrial Sustainability
Ensures reliable process water supply.
Agricultural Support
Provides nutrient-controlled irrigation water.
Pollution Reduction
Minimizes discharge into rivers and lakes.
Climate Resilience
Strengthens drought preparedness.
The Future: Toward Zero Liquid Discharge (ZLD)
Advanced municipalities and industries are moving toward Zero Liquid Discharge, where:
- All wastewater is treated
- Recovered for reuse
- No effluent is discharged
This requires multi-stage treatment far beyond BOD removal but represents the gold standard of water sustainability.
Conclusion
Biological Oxygen Demand remains a foundational indicator of sewage treatment performance—but it is only one piece of the water quality puzzle.
Many Sewage Treatment Plants successfully meet BOD discharge limits, demonstrating effective removal of biodegradable organic matter. Yet reuse applications demand far higher treatment sophistication.
Residual nutrients, dissolved salts, pathogens, heavy metals, and synthetic chemicals often persist in treated effluent—rendering it unsuitable for irrigation, industrial processes, or potable reuse.
To close this gap, STPs must adopt:
- Tertiary and advanced treatment technologies
- Multi-parameter monitoring systems
- Robust disinfection processes
- Nutrient and salt removal solutions
Moving beyond BOD-centric treatment is essential for achieving safe, reliable, and sustainable water reuse—especially in water-stressed regions.
Need Expert Guidance on Water & Wastewater Treatment Solutions?
If you are planning to upgrade your STP for reuse compliance or install a new treatment system, expert consultation can help you choose the most efficient and cost-effective technology.
For assistance, technical support, or project inquiries:
📞 Call: +91-9560654995
📧 Email: sales@vaqua.in
Share your water treatment challenge—our experts will help you design the right solution for long-term performance and compliance.
